Business Owner Deferred Compensation Strategies: How to Reduce Taxes and Build Long-Term Wealth

This is where deferred compensation planning can become valuable.
The concept is simple. Instead of receiving all your compensation today, you look for opportunities to move some of that income into future years. The objective isn’t just to get a tax deduction this year. The real goal is to shift income away from your highest tax years while building assets that can eventually replace the income you receive from your business.
Start With Your Existing 401(k) and Profit-Sharing Plan
The first place I would typically start is with the company’s existing retirement plan.
A standard 401(k) is useful, but business owners shouldn’t assume that maxing out their employee contribution means they have exhausted their retirement planning opportunities. Depending on the structure and demographics of the company, the plan can potentially be designed to direct significantly more employer contributions toward owners and other key employees.
This is where working with a good third-party administrator, or TPA, becomes important. The TPA can run different plan designs based on employee ages, compensation, ownership, and census information. Instead of simply asking, “How much can I put into my 401(k)?” I would ask, “What is the maximum amount I can reasonably contribute for myself while still providing an appropriate benefit to my employees and complying with the retirement plan rules?”
That is a very different conversation.
Adding a Cash Balance Plan
For highly profitable businesses, the next step may be adding a cash balance plan. A cash balance plan is a type of defined benefit retirement plan that can sit alongside a 401(k) and profit-sharing plan. Depending on the owner’s age, compensation, plan design, and other factors, it may create the opportunity for substantially larger deductible employer contributions.
This strategy tends to work particularly well for an owner who is approaching retirement, has consistent business cash flow, and hasn’t accumulated enough retirement assets outside the company.
For example, imagine a business owner in their 50s who is earning $700,000 per year. They may already be maximizing what they can put into their 401(k), but they are still recognizing hundreds of thousands of dollars of taxable income each year. Rather than simply accepting the tax bill, we can have the TPA and actuary model a 401(k), profit-sharing, and cash balance plan together.
Model Contributions, Costs, and Funding Commitments
The important word here is model.
You don’t want to establish a plan based on a hypothetical tax savings number and then discover that the required employee contributions or future funding commitments don’t make sense for the business. Before implementing anything, I want to see exactly how many dollars go to the owner, how many dollars have to go to employees, the estimated tax benefit, administrative costs, and what happens if business profitability declines.
Once those numbers make sense, the CPA needs to be involved to confirm the tax implications and the business needs to establish and operate the plans within the applicable rules and deadlines.
Understanding Nonqualified Deferred Compensation
There is another category of planning that becomes interesting when qualified retirement plans aren’t enough: nonqualified deferred compensation.
A nonqualified deferred compensation arrangement can potentially allow an owner or executive to defer compensation beyond the limits applicable to qualified retirement plans. But this isn’t simply an investment account where you decide at the end of December that you don’t want to pay taxes on $200,000 of income.
These arrangements must be structured correctly.
Generally, elections regarding when compensation will be deferred and when it will eventually be paid need to be made in advance and must comply with applicable tax rules, including Internal Revenue Code Section 409A. Getting the timing wrong can create significant tax consequences, which is why an attorney and CPA familiar with deferred compensation should be involved before the arrangement is established.
There is also an important distinction between qualified retirement money and nonqualified deferred compensation. Assets inside a qualified retirement plan are generally held for the benefit of plan participants. With many nonqualified arrangements, the employee essentially has a contractual promise from the company to pay the compensation in the future. That means the financial strength of the company and potential creditor exposure matter.
Align Deferred Compensation With Your Business Exit Plan
For owners of closely held businesses, there is another issue I think is particularly important: the exit plan.
Suppose you are 55 today, expect to sell your business at 62, and currently earn $800,000 per year. Those seven years before the sale may be some of the highest taxable-income years of your life. But the years immediately following the sale could look completely different.
That creates a planning window.
Instead of looking at each year’s tax return independently, I want to build a multi-year tax projection. We estimate business income, retirement contributions, investment income, the potential business sale, Social Security, required minimum distributions, and other future income sources. Then we identify the years where income can potentially be moved from one tax period to another.
Maybe the strategy is maximizing a 401(k) and profit-sharing plan today. Maybe a cash balance plan makes sense for the next seven years. Maybe a properly structured deferred compensation arrangement creates income after the owner leaves the business. In other cases, the better strategy might be taking the income today and investing it in a taxable account because we don’t want to create an enormous taxable distribution later.
Tax Deferral and Future Tax Liability
That last point is important.
Tax deferral is not the same thing as tax savings.
If you defer $200,000 today and eventually withdraw that $200,000 plus decades of growth at the same or a higher tax rate, the outcome may not be nearly as attractive as it initially appeared. We have to compare today’s deduction against tomorrow’s expected tax liability.
Coordinate Your Financial, Tax, and Retirement Plan Professionals
This is why I don’t believe business owners should implement these strategies one at a time.
The financial advisor should model the long-term financial impact. The CPA should analyze the current and future tax consequences. The TPA and actuary should determine what can actually be accomplished through qualified retirement plans. An ERISA or benefits attorney may be necessary for more complicated arrangements. And all of this needs to fit with the owner’s eventual business exit strategy.
When these professionals are working independently, opportunities are often missed.
Compare Strategies Before Establishing a New Plan
For a business owner who wants to explore deferred compensation, I would start by gathering the company census, current retirement plan documents, recent business and personal tax returns, expected business cash flow, and an estimated retirement or business-sale date. From there, model several alternatives rather than immediately implementing a new plan.
Compare the status quo against an enhanced 401(k)/profit-sharing design, a 401(k) combined with a cash balance plan, and when appropriate a nonqualified deferred compensation strategy. Then look at the cumulative contributions, employee costs, estimated tax impact, administrative expenses, future distributions, and projected retirement assets.
The best strategy isn’t necessarily the one that produces the largest deduction this year.
It’s the one that allows you to take money that is currently trapped inside a high-income tax year and reposition it in a way that gives you greater flexibility later.
Business owners spend decades building an asset that is supposed to eventually provide financial independence. Deferred compensation planning can help make sure you’re also building wealth outside of that business along the way.
The goal isn’t simply to pay less tax this year. It’s to control when you recognize income, diversify your wealth away from the business, and create multiple sources of income for the day when you no longer want or need to own the company.
A Deferred Compensation Case Study
Let’s put some numbers around this.
Assume we are working with a 55-year-old business owner earning approximately $750,000 per year. The company is consistently profitable, the owner has 10 employees, and they expect to sell or transition out of the business around age 65. The owner is already maximizing their 401(k), but most of the remaining business income is flowing through to their personal tax return each year.
This is exactly the type of situation where I would want to run a retirement plan design study.
Compare the Existing Plan With Expanded Retirement Options
The first scenario is simply continuing what the owner is already doing. They maximize their individual 401(k) contribution, receive whatever employer contribution the existing plan provides, pay the resulting income taxes, and invest additional savings in a taxable brokerage account.
There is nothing necessarily wrong with that strategy. In fact, we need it as our baseline because every additional layer of complexity needs to produce enough benefit to justify its cost.
The second scenario is redesigning the company’s 401(k) and profit-sharing plan. We would give the employee census to a TPA and ask them to model different contribution formulas. Depending on employee ages and compensation, the company may be able to make a substantially larger profit-sharing contribution for the owner while also making the required contributions for eligible employees.
Then we model a third scenario: adding a cash balance plan.
For illustration, suppose the combined retirement plan design allows the owner to contribute approximately $200,000 more annually toward retirement than under the existing plan. The actual number could be significantly higher or lower, so this is where the actuary and TPA need to do the real calculations.
Now assume that additional $200,000 contribution produces approximately $70,000 of current federal and state income tax savings. Again, that number will depend on the owner’s actual marginal tax rates and circumstances.
Account for Employee Benefits and Administrative Expenses
This is where business owners sometimes make a mistake. They focus on the $70,000 tax savings and assume the strategy is automatically a good deal.
I don’t look at it that way.
First, we need to determine the additional cost of providing benefits to employees. Suppose the redesigned plans require another $30,000 per year of employee contributions and administrative expenses. I wouldn’t ignore that cost just because the owner receives a tax deduction for it. It’s still real money leaving the business.
In simplified terms, we might spend an additional $30,000 to create the opportunity for the owner to move $200,000 from current taxable income into a retirement account while potentially reducing the current tax bill by roughly $70,000.
Now we have something worth analyzing.
Project Retirement Assets and Future Distributions
If the owner does this for 10 years, they could potentially redirect $2 million of additional contributions into retirement accounts before considering any investment growth. If those dollars earn an average hypothetical return of 6% annually, the additional retirement assets could grow to roughly $2.6 million by the end of the tenth year.
But remember that $2.6 million isn’t tax-free money. Distributions from tax-deferred retirement accounts will generally be taxable. That’s why our analysis can’t stop at age 65.
Suppose the owner sells the company at 65 and no longer receives $750,000 of annual business income. We may now have an opportunity to strategically distribute retirement assets during lower-income years. Depending on the owner’s circumstances, we might also evaluate Roth conversions, charitable giving strategies, and the timing of Social Security and other income sources.
On the other hand, if the business sale itself generates significant taxable income or the owner already has several million dollars in tax-deferred retirement accounts, aggressively deferring another $2 million might not be the best answer. We could simply be exchanging today’s tax problem for tomorrow’s tax problem.
This is why I would build a year-by-year projection before establishing the plan.
I want to see the owner’s estimated taxable income from age 55 through at least their 80s. Then we can compare the projected taxes under the existing strategy with the projected taxes after implementing the new retirement plans. We can also see what happens to future required minimum distributions and whether we are creating opportunities for tax planning between retirement and those distributions.
Build Wealth Outside Your Business
There is one more benefit that shouldn’t be overlooked.
Without the plan, much of the owner’s net worth may remain concentrated in the company. That’s common among successful entrepreneurs. They might have a $5 million business but comparatively little accumulated in investments outside of it.
Redirecting $200,000 per year into retirement accounts isn’t just a tax strategy. It is gradually moving wealth from the business owner’s largest concentrated asset, the company into a diversified portfolio that isn’t dependent on what someone is willing to pay for the business ten years from now.
That’s a very different way to think about deferred compensation.
The question isn’t, “How do I get the biggest tax deduction this year?”
The better question is, “How much of today’s business income can I strategically move into future years, what does it cost me to do it, and does that leave me with more after-tax wealth over my lifetime?”
That’s the calculation that ultimately matters.
Do you have more questions? We are here to help! Schedule a complimentary consultation today.
Casey Smith
President, Wiser Wealth Management
Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!
Wiser Wealth Management, Inc (“Wiser Wealth”) is a registered investment adviser with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). As a registered investment adviser, Wiser Wealth and its employees are subject to various rules, filings, and requirements. You can visit the SEC’s website here to obtain further information on our firm or investment adviser’s registration.
Wiser Wealth’s website provides general information regarding our business along with access to additional investment related information, various financial calculators, and external / third party links. Material presented on this website is believed to be from reliable sources and is meant for informational purposes only. Wiser Wealth does not endorse or accept responsibility for the content of any third-party website and is not affiliated with any third-party website or social media page. Wiser Wealth does not expressly or implicitly adopt or endorse any of the expressions, opinions or content posted by third party websites or on social media pages. While Wiser Wealth uses reasonable efforts to obtain information from sources it believes to be reliable, we make no representation that the information or opinions contained in our publications are accurate, reliable, or complete.
To the extent that you utilize any financial calculators or links in our website, you acknowledge and understand that the information provided to you should not be construed as personal investment advice from Wiser Wealth or any of its investment professionals. Advice provided by Wiser Wealth is given only within the context of our contractual agreement with the client. Wiser Wealth does not offer legal, accounting or tax advice. Consult your own attorney, accountant, and other professionals for these services.





