Two-Bucket Investing Strategy: Income Strategy vs Total Return

You might have heard your parents or even grandparents talk about buying individual securities. Specifically, the ones that pay dividends. Many investment experts will agree that this approach to investing is not sustainable in the long term. However, dividend-paying stocks have come back in the news recently. With interest rates now rising, people are more focused on yield. This is only natural, but you need to understand the contrast between two different approaches.

Dividend-Paying Stocks vs. Total Market Stocks

Our investment manager ran some numbers based on historical facts for a potential 10-year future scenario. It’s important to understand that only some industries pay high dividends. Therefore, a dividend-focused approach to investing in stocks can lead to a non-diversified portfolio. With that, you’d end up missing out on another important aspect of an investment portfolio: growth.

Therefore, the scenario created showed two types of portfolios, one that was heavy on dividend stocks. We called it SDY. An ETF focused on dividend payers. Compared to SPTM, which represents a total US market portfolio. Now, this is a very diverse portfolio, also containing dividend-paying stocks, but not limited to that. In a 10-year forecast based on the history of the stock market, SDY yielded $419K in distributions. Its ending value was $2.1M. The SPTM yielded $504K in total distributions and its ending value was $2.4M.

That is a total value of $2.9M in the SPTM. Opposed to a $2.5M in total value for SDY. This goes to show the importance of a diversified portfolio. For an optimized return on your stock market investments, it’s essential to focus on value and growth.

Download our eBook: “Top Reasons Most Financial Plans Fail”

Have more questions? Contact Us

Casey Smith
President, Wiser Wealth Management

Click here to schedule a consultation with one of our financial planners.

Listen to Our Podcast:


Recent posts

  • Is there a downside to paying off a mortgage early?
  • Does lump sum investing beat dollar cost averaging?

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Wiser Wealth Management, Inc (“Wiser Wealth”) is a registered investment adviser with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). As a registered investment adviser, Wiser Wealth and its employees are subject to various rules, filings, and requirements. You can visit the SEC’s website here to obtain further information on our firm or investment adviser’s registration.

Wiser Wealth’s website provides general information regarding our business along with access to additional investment related information, various financial calculators, and external / third party links. Material presented on this website is believed to be from reliable sources and is meant for informational purposes only. Wiser Wealth does not endorse or accept responsibility for the content of any third-party website and is not affiliated with any third-party website or social media page. Wiser Wealth does not expressly or implicitly adopt or endorse any of the expressions, opinions or content posted by third party websites or on social media pages. While Wiser Wealth uses reasonable efforts to obtain information from sources it believes to be reliable, we make no representation that the information or opinions contained in our publications are accurate, reliable, or complete.

To the extent that you utilize any financial calculators or links in our website, you acknowledge and understand that the information provided to you should not be construed as personal investment advice from Wiser Wealth or any of its investment professionals. Advice provided by Wiser Wealth is given only within the context of our contractual agreement with the client. Wiser Wealth does not offer legal, accounting or tax advice. Consult your own attorney, accountant, and other professionals for these services.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Our latest blogs, podcasts, and educational videos delivered to your inbox weekly.